AI receptionist comparison
Smith.ai alternative with a CRM built in: GateKeeperAI compared
GateKeeperAI is a Smith.ai alternative for owners who want the AI receptionist and a CRM on one bill, from $149 a month. At 120 calls a month it costs less than Smith.ai AI Pro when calls average under about 5.3 minutes, and more above that. Pick Smith.ai if you want live human receptionists.
Their details checked on by Vyron Johnson. Smith.ai is a trademark of its owner. GateKeeperAI is not affiliated with Smith.ai. Prices and features change, so check their site before you buy.
| What we compared | GateKeeperAI | Smith.ai |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers the call | Our AI on the AI Receptionist plan. On Capture and Operate the call rings through to you | Live receptionists on their Virtual Receptionist plans, or their AI on the AI Receptionist plans |
| Starting monthly price | AI Receptionist from $149. CRM alone from $40 | AI: free for 25 calls with a card at signup, Pro from $150. Live: Starter at $300 |
| What the starting price includes | 300 talk minutes on Starter, more on higher plans, plus the full CRM | AI Pro: 75 calls. Live Starter: 30 calls |
| Overage | $0.45 a minute past your plan's talk minutes | AI Pro: $2.50 a call on the 75 call tier, $2.30 on 150, $2.17 on 300. Live Starter: $11.50 a call |
| Setup fee | $250 one time on the AI plans, paid at signup | No setup fees listed. AI Pro includes onboarding support, and Enterprise lists full service setup |
| Booking appointments | Included on Operate and AI Receptionist | Included on AI plans. $1.50 a call on live plans |
| Live transfer | To your team during business hours | Warm transfers on AI plans. Live Starter includes 1 transfer destination |
| Call recording and transcripts | Transcripts included. Recordings included on Capture and Operate, enabled on request for AI Receptionist | Included on AI plans. $0.25 a call on live plans |
| CRM and pipeline | Built in: contacts, a drag and drop pipeline and tasks | Sends call details to your CRM, such as HubSpot or Salesforce |
| Web forms and Facebook and Instagram lead ads | Included on every plan | Not listed on their pricing page |
| Google reviews | On Operate and up. Replies to 4 star and up reviews are written by the AI and posted automatically, under 4 stars arrive as a draft you approve | Not listed on their pricing page |
| Contract or trial | 14 day free trial on Capture and Operate, card at signup. Cancel any time from billing settings | Month to month. AI plans ask for 30 days notice to cancel. Live plans list a 30 day money back offer for new clients |
Smith.ai sells both live and AI answering. Which one you use changes the comparison: live human receptionists billed per call, or an AI receptionist also billed per call at a much lower rate. As a Smith.ai alternative, GateKeeperAI sells an AI receptionist billed by the minute with a CRM included, plus CRM plans where calls ring through to you. This comparison is published by GateKeeperAI. Every Smith.ai detail below comes from their own pages, checked on October 2, 2026.
What Smith.ai sells and who it suits
The Virtual Receptionist plans put people on your line. Starter is $300 a month for 30 calls, Basic is $810 for 90, and Pro is $2,100 for 300, with extra calls at $11.50, $10.50 and $8.50. Lead screening, intake questions and 24/7 live staffing are listed as included, with no setup fee. Booking, recording, a Spanish line and payment collection are per call add ons.
The AI Receptionist plans start with a free tier of 25 calls a month, which takes a card at signup, then Pro at $150 for 75 calls, $270 for 150, or $500 for 300, with extra calls at $2.50, $2.30 and $2.17. Recording, transcripts, scheduling through tools such as Calendly, and native integrations are core features. Their AI product page says calls can be escalated to their North America based live receptionists, with no fee when the AI starts the escalation.
It suits a business that already runs a CRM it likes, wants the phone handled, and wants a person available on harder calls.
When Smith.ai is the better pick
- You want a human on the line. Smith.ai staffs live receptionists around the clock, and GateKeeperAI does not offer human answering.
- You want a person behind the AI after hours. Our live transfer reaches your own team during your business hours. Smith.ai's AI can escalate a caller to their live receptionists at any hour, free when the AI starts the escalation.
- Your calls run long. Smith.ai bills per call rather than per minute. Its live service charges separately for extended intake and other additional work under its reasonable use policy, so confirm the price for your intake. We bill by the minute past your plan's talk minutes, so long calls cost more with us. The worked example below uses their AI plan prices, with one live plan row for reference.
- Your callers speak Spanish. Their AI plan lists English and Spanish on every tier, and the live plans offer a Spanish line at $1.00 a call. Our plan pages do not list Spanish answering.
- You already live in another CRM. Their pricing page names HubSpot, Salesforce and Clio, and their integrations directory lists tools such as Calendly, Acuity and 3CX. If moving off your CRM is not on the table, sending calls into it is the shorter path.
- You get only a few calls a month. Their free AI tier covers 25 calls with a card at signup, and they say setup takes about 15 minutes on your own. Our AI plans start at $149, and the AI answers after a setup call with us.
Where GateKeeperAI is a different kind of Smith.ai alternative
Smith.ai counts calls and sends the details to whatever CRM you connect, at $0.50 a call for each CRM past the first on the live plans. GateKeeperAI counts minutes, and the CRM is part of the plan: the AI Receptionist plan includes everything in Operate, from the pipeline to web forms, lead ads and online booking. A call the AI answers is written into that pipeline as a lead. Replies to 4 star and up Google reviews are written by the AI and posted automatically, and under 4 stars arrive as a draft you approve. Smith.ai's pricing pages do not list a review tool.
Our setup is a call where we write your intake questions with you, set business hours and transfer numbers, and train your team on the pipeline. You approve the questions before the AI takes a call. The setup fee is $250 one time, paid when you buy the plan. If you do not want an AI answering at all, the CRM plans start at $40 a month: your number rings through to you, and callers hear a short recording notice before the forwarded call connects.
What each costs at 120 calls a month
Take a home service business that gets 120 answered calls a month and books 40 of them. Swap in your own numbers. Our rows use the cheapest GateKeeperAI plan for each month, plus a one time setup fee of $250.
| Option | Arithmetic | Monthly total |
|---|---|---|
| GateKeeperAI Standard, 4 minute calls | 120 × 4 = 480 minutes, inside the 500 included on Standard | $200 |
| GateKeeperAI Standard, 10 minute calls | Standard, $200 with 500 minutes, plus 700 extra minutes × $0.45 | $515 |
| Smith.ai AI Receptionist Pro, 75 call tier | $150 + 45 extra calls × $2.50 | $262.50 |
| Smith.ai AI Receptionist Pro, 150 call tier | Flat, covers all 120 calls | $270 |
| Smith.ai Virtual Receptionists Basic | $810 + 30 extra calls × $10.50 + 40 bookings × $1.50, before any extended intake fees | $1,185 |
With 4 minute calls, our Standard plan is lower: $200 a month plus the $250 setup fee, CRM included. With 10 minute calls, Smith.ai AI Pro plus extra calls is lower, at $262.50 against our $515. At 120 calls the two meet at about 5.32 minutes a call. Live receptionists cost well above either AI option here.
The Smith.ai AI figures do not include a separate CRM, so add yours if you pay for one. Neither vendor charges for every ring: their AI plans filter known spam numbers, and we bill talk minutes. For more, see the AI receptionist cost math.
Confirm which calls are billable
- Which calls count toward my quota, and how do I take spam calls off the bill?
- At my call count, is a higher tier cheaper than the lower tier plus extra calls?
- Does my intake fit inside the standard call, or will it be billed as extended intake?
- Does the money back offer cover the plan I am choosing, and how much notice do I give to cancel?
For us, the matching question is your average call length. For the wider choice, our AI receptionist vs answering service breakdown lays out what each does well.
Switching from Smith.ai, or running both
Their AI plans ask for 30 days notice to cancel, and their live plans bill through the end of the current monthly cycle. New clients on the live plans get a 30 day money back offer, up to $1,000 for the plan and add ons, overage calls excluded. The same FAQ answer also mentions deciding in the first two weeks, so confirm the window with them. Give notice, then set up GateKeeperAI and run a test call before you move your call forwarding.
To keep Smith.ai's live receptionists, you could still put web forms, website chat and lead ads into a GateKeeperAI pipeline on the $40 Capture plan. Trade specific details are on the home services page, and every plan is on the pricing page.
Other Smith.ai alternatives we compared
- GateKeeperAI vs Ruby
Ruby puts a live receptionist on every call, billed by the minute. GateKeeperAI answers with an AI from $149 a month and includes the CRM. Where each one fits, with the math.
- GateKeeperAI vs Rosie
Rosie is a self serve AI answering service from $49 a month. GateKeeperAI costs more and pairs the AI receptionist with a full CRM, set up with you on a call.
- GateKeeperAI vs Goodcall
Goodcall bills per agent with unlimited minutes and an allowance of unique callers, then $0.50 per additional caller. GateKeeperAI bills by talk minutes and includes a full CRM.
- GateKeeperAI vs GoHighLevel
HighLevel is an all in one marketing platform with agency plans from $97 a month. GateKeeperAI is a narrower CRM and AI receptionist for one owner, from $40.